5 Year Aged White Cheddar
5 Year Aged Yellow Cheddar
5 Year Aged Yellow Cheddar Cheese
5 Year Aged White Cheddar

5 Year Aged White Cheddar

Regular price$15.00
Shipping calculated at checkout.

NOTE: We have changed our 5 Year Aged Yellow Cheddar to White Cheddar.

1/2 lb. (8 oz.)

This Extra Sharp Cheddar has aged over 5 years. This is for those that appreciate the true taste of cheddar! Many find that this cheese strikes the perfect balance between sharpness and the creamy texture. As cheddar ages it loses its smooth, firm texture and becomes more granular and crumbly.

There’s a lot of flavor and texture going on with aged cheddar, so you want a drink that stands up to that but doesn’t overpower it. We like off-dry, mature beverages that have just a touch of sweetness like Saison ale, cider, bock and Belgian ales. For wine, we recommend Riesling, chardonnay and champagne (whites) and Syrah, pinot noir and chianti (reds). Bourbon and single malt scotch are always sure bets too.


Due to the perishable nature of our products, we do not ship over the weekend. Most orders placed Thursday-Sunday will ship the following Monday, unless Saturday delivery is available in your area. We will notify you with a tracking number once your package ships.

Recently viewed

Product Info

All of our cheeses are handcrafted by Master Cheesemakers in small batches using only the best ingredients in Southern Wisconsin.

Because our cheese is hand-cut, your cheese may arrive slightly more or slightly less than listed net weight.

Return & Refund Policy​

Unless the product is damaged or defective, there is a no return or exchange policy. Customer Satisfaction is important to us, so please contact us with any issues.

Shipping Info

For special orders items, please allow 2 - 3 weeks. Please note: To avoid weekend transit, orders placed after 1 PM ET on Wednesday will ship on Monday of the following week.


We've got your 'burger covered'!

Create a little gourmet magic on the grill with our unique cheese selection. Mexican Burger? Mediterranean Burger? Bleu Cheese Burger? Pizza Burger?