Cheese

Filter

    A diverse selection of handcrafted cheeses, each with unique flavors and characteristics. Our cheeses are made in small batches using high-quality ingredients sourced from small family-owned farms in Wisconsin. The product line includes a variety of styles and flavors to suit different palates.

    89 products
    Aged Yellow Cheddar
    12 Year Aged White Cheddar
    $40.00
    15 Year Aged white Cheddar
    $54.00
    2 Year Aged White Cheddar
    from $8.00
    5 Year Aged Yellow Cheddar
    5 Year Aged White Cheddar
    from $14.00
    7 Year Aged White Cheddar
    from $16.00
    7 Year Aged Yellow Cheddar
    7 Year Aged Yellow Cheddar cheese
    7 Year Aged Yellow Cheddar
    from $16.00
    Sold Out
    All Natural String Cheese & Turkey Bacon (Baconwich)
    $3.00
    Asiago Cheese
    Asiago
    $9.00
    Asiago w/ Rosemary
    $10.00
    Baby Swiss Cheese
    Swiss and Spinach Crustles Quiche
    Baby Swiss
    from $10.00
    Cheddar Cheese Bacon Burger
    Bacon Cheddar
    from $10.00
    BellaVitano Espresso
    $10.00
    BellaVitano Merlot
    $10.00
    BellaVitano Tennessee Whiskey
    $10.00
    Black Truffle Goat Cheese
    Black Truffle Goat
    $15.00
    Sold Out
    Bleu Cheese
    Bleu Cheese
    Blue Cheese
    $12.00
    Blue Cheese Cheddar
    from $11.00
    Bleu Marble Jack Cheese
    Blue Marble Burger
    Blue Marble Jack
    from $10.00
    Blueberry Infused Cheddar Cheese
    Blueberry Infused Cheddar
    from $10.00
    Sold Out
    Bread Cheese
    $12.00
    Brick Cheese
    BrickApp
    Brick
    $15.00
    Brie Wheel
    $16.00
    Buffalo Cheddar
    from $10.00
    Caraway Cheddar
    from $11.00
    Sale
    Cheese Curds - Maple Bacon
    $11.00 $8.00 Save $3.00
    Sale
    Cheese Curds - White Garlic & Dill
    $11.00 $9.00 Save $2.00
    Sale
    Cheese Curds - Plain White
    Cheese Curds Poutine
    Cheese Curds - White Plain
    $10.00 $8.00 Save $2.00
    Sold Out
    Cheese Curds - Yellow Garlic & Dill
    $11.00
    Cheese Curds Batter Mix
    $6.00
    Cheesewich
    $4.00
    Cherry Infused Cheddar Cheese
    Blueberry Cranberry
    Cherry Infused Cheddar
    from $10.00
    Chipotle Bread Cheese
    $12.00
    Chipotle Cheddar
    Chipotle Cheddar
    from $10.00
    Cinnamon Apple Cheddar
    from $10.00
    Cranberry Infused Cheddar Cheese
    Cranberry Infused Cheddar Cheese
    Cranberry Infused Cheddar
    from $10.00
    Sold Out
    Dill Havarti Cheese
    Dill Havarti Cheese
    Dill Havarti
    from $9.00
    Dragon's Breath Cheddar
    from $13.00
    Sold Out
    Edam
    $19.00
    Farmers Cheese
    from $11.00
    Farmers Cheese - Dill
    from $11.00
    Farmers Cheese - Jalapeno Pepper
    from $11.00
    Sold Out
    Fresh Mozzarella - Lioni's
    from $9.00
    Garlic & Dill Cheddar
    from $11.00
    Garlic & Herb Cheese Spread
    Garlic & Herb Cheese Spread
    $11.00
    Garlic & Herb Jack
    from $10.00
    Sold Out
    Garlic Bread Cheese
    $12.00
    Sale
    Ghost Pepper Jack
    $12.00 from $11.00 Save $1.00
    Sold Out
    Gorgonzola Cheese
    Gorgonzola Cheese
    Gorgonzola
    $12.00
    Gouda
    Gouda-Creamy-Veggie-Chopped-Salad
    Gouda
    $19.00
    Greek Style Traditional Feta
    Feta Log
    Greek Style Traditional Feta
    $8.00
    Havarti
    havarti honeydew stacks
    Havarti
    from $7.00
    Sale
    Horseradish Cheddar
    $12.00 $7.20 Save $4.80
    Horseradish Havarti
    Havarti Spicy Peach Super Sandwich
    Horseradish Havarti
    from $9.00
    Sale
    Insulated Cooler
    $7.00 $4.00 Save $3.00
    Sale
    Italian Truffle Cheese Spread
    $11.00 $9.00 Save $2.00
    LaClare Blueberry Vanilla Goat Cheese
    $8.00
    LaClare Everything Bagel Spice Goat Cheese
    $8.00
    LaClare Fig & Honey Goat Cheese
    $8.00
    LaClare Garlic & Herb Goat Cheese
    $8.00
    LaClare Original Goat Cheese
    $8.00
    Limburger
    Limburger-MacandCheese
    Limburger
    $12.00
    Manchego
    $18.00
    Marieke Raw Milk Honey Clover Gouda
    $13.00
    Sold Out
    Marieke Raw Milk Summer Fields Gouda
    $13.00
    Marieke Raw Milk Truffle Gouda
    $15.00
    Marieke Raw Milk Young Gouda
    $13.00
    Maytag Bleu Cheese Crumbles
    $11.00
    Maytag Bleu Cheese
    Maytag Bleu Cheese
    Maytag Bleu Cheese Wedge
    $16.00
    Sold Out
    Mediterranean Cheddar
    from $12.00
    Mobay
    $15.00
    Morel and Leek Jack Cheese
    Morel and Leek Jack
    from $10.00
    Mozzarella Cheese
    Mozzarella MushroomPizza
    Mozzarella
    $11.00